Guide

Butterfly valve vs gate valve vs ball valve: which is better?

Use a butterfly valve for large water and air lines, a gate (sluice) valve where the bore must be fully clear, and a ball valve for small lines that need a quick, tight shut-off.

Published · Updated

All three isolate a line. They differ in how much space they take, how much they cost in large sizes, and what they leave in the flow path.

Butterfly valveGate (sluice) valveBall valve
OperationQuarter turnMany turns of a handwheelQuarter turn
Face to faceShortestLongMedium
Weight in large sizesLightHeavyHeavy
Bore when openDisc stays in the flowFully clearFully clear (full bore)
Pressure dropLow to moderateLowestLowest (full bore)
ThrottlingYes, within its rangeNoNot recommended
Typical useWater, cooling water, air, from DN 50 upWater mains, sewage, slurryUtilities, chemicals, fuel, up to about DN 200

Butterfly or gate valve on a water main?

On most mains above DN 200, a double-flanged butterfly valve costs and weighs a fraction of a sluice valve and operates faster. Choose the sluice valve where the line must be pigged or swabbed, where solids would catch on a disc, or where the specification names IS 14846.

Ball or butterfly valve?

Below DN 100, a ball valve seals tighter and lasts longer on frequent operation. Above DN 150, a butterfly valve is lighter and more economical.

Gate or ball valve for a main line shut-off?

On a small main line, a full-bore ball valve: it shuts in a quarter turn and seals tighter. On large water mains, a sluice or butterfly valve.

Need it quoted?

Send your BOQ, drawing or list of sizes through Request a quote. One quotation for the complete line.

Ranges in this guide:Butterfly valvesGate and sluice valvesBall valves

A size or rating not listed?

Our procurement desk sources it, from Valvetech or anywhere in the world.