All three isolate a line. They differ in how much space they take, how much they cost in large sizes, and what they leave in the flow path.
| Butterfly valve | Gate (sluice) valve | Ball valve | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Operation | Quarter turn | Many turns of a handwheel | Quarter turn |
| Face to face | Shortest | Long | Medium |
| Weight in large sizes | Light | Heavy | Heavy |
| Bore when open | Disc stays in the flow | Fully clear | Fully clear (full bore) |
| Pressure drop | Low to moderate | Lowest | Lowest (full bore) |
| Throttling | Yes, within its range | No | Not recommended |
| Typical use | Water, cooling water, air, from DN 50 up | Water mains, sewage, slurry | Utilities, chemicals, fuel, up to about DN 200 |
Butterfly or gate valve on a water main?
On most mains above DN 200, a double-flanged butterfly valve costs and weighs a fraction of a sluice valve and operates faster. Choose the sluice valve where the line must be pigged or swabbed, where solids would catch on a disc, or where the specification names IS 14846.
Ball or butterfly valve?
Below DN 100, a ball valve seals tighter and lasts longer on frequent operation. Above DN 150, a butterfly valve is lighter and more economical.
Gate or ball valve for a main line shut-off?
On a small main line, a full-bore ball valve: it shuts in a quarter turn and seals tighter. On large water mains, a sluice or butterfly valve.
Need it quoted?
Send your BOQ, drawing or list of sizes through Request a quote. One quotation for the complete line.
Ranges in this guide:Butterfly valvesGate and sluice valvesBall valves